Turner Network Television's BUFFALO SOLDIERS is a dramatic composite, inspired
in part by actual historical events. The filmmaker's aim is to illustrate the
larger themes of citizenship, service and racial equality. In presenting this
film, TNT hopes to shed light on the little-known Buffalo Soldiers and, in turn,
create a forum for dialogue regarding this important, but almost forgotten,
chapter in American history.
The date is July 1880. The setting is the Trans-Pecos territory along the
borders of Texas, New Mexico and Mexico. Victorio, the leader of the Mescalero
Apache, has killed many American settlers on the frontier and continues to out-
maneuver the U.S. military. Buffalo Soldiers begins as Troop H, the Buffalo
Soldier unit under the leadership of Sergeant Major Washington Wyatt, intercepts
the Texas Rangers, who are lynching Apaches in an effort to elicit information
about Victorio's whereabouts. The Rangers, like the Buffalo Soldiers, are
aggressively pursuing Victorio. Yet while their goals are the same, to enable
safe settlement of Americans in the Texas territory - their methods are very
different. The Buffalo Soldiers put an end to the lynchings and return to their
fort to report the events of the day to General Leonidas Pike.
Although the mission of the Buffalo Soldiers is to carry out the U.S.
government's public policy of westward expansion, the African-American
troops are not treated as equals in the U.S. military. They are called
derogatory names and are required to perform menial labor. Many White
commanders refuse to command Troop H. General Pike himself, considered
by many to be the perfect soldier, contends that African-American soldiers
"are trained to take orders, not to give them."
The only White officer who supports the unit is Regimental Commanding
Officer Colonel Benjamin Grierson. Ostracized by other officers for his
enthusiastic command of the African-American troops, Grierson believes
in the abilities, dedication, and record of performance of the Buffalo
Soldiers and declines offers to lead at any other post. General Pike
offers to relieve Grierson "of this self-imposed exile and have him
commanding a real cavalry regiment within a month," but Grierson
refuses.
While out on assignment, the Buffalo Soldiers are attacked by Victorio's
Apaches. Despite suffering casualties, they take prisoners, including
Nana, another Apache leader who has knowledge of Victorio's whereabouts.
Heroics not withstanding, the troops are denied accolades for bringing in
a valuable prisoner.
Colonel Grierson realizes the only way to capture Victorio is to guard
all of the water holes between his men and the Mexican border. Troop H
heads for Rattlesnake Springs, New Mexico, but Grierson is wounded and
returns to the fort. Sergeant Major Wyatt an African-American, is left
in command.
Able to beat the Apaches to Rattlesnake Springs, the Buffalo Soldiers
gain the high ground on Victorio and the Apache men, women and children.
It is at this time that Sergeant Major Wyatt ponders the irony of the
situation; he observes this nation of people who have been ruthlessly
mistreated and reflects on his own life of slavery. He, a man freed
from slavery less than 20 years before, now must follow orders and murder
American Indians in order to provide safe passage for the White settlers.
Wyatt is not alone in doubting the morality of his orders. His men share
in this profound moral dilemma. Does he refuse to follow the orders of
the U.S. government and face a court-martial and disgrace; or does he kill
innocent people and lose his ability to stand tall before his troop and
himself?

Sergeant Major Washington Wyatt: A fictional character, he represents
the dedication, bravery and excellence of the Buffalo Soldiers. A former
slave and son of slaves, Wyatt has made the military his life.
Colonel Benjamin Grierson: Colonel Grierson was the White commander of
the Tenth cavalry of the Buffalo Soldiers. He worked 17 years with the
Buffalo Soldiers and was proud of their accomplishments.
General Leonidas Pike: Commanding officer of the fort, Pike believes
the African-American troops are inferior.
John Horse: Horse is a Seminole/Negro Indian Scout hired by General
Pike to help find Victorio.
Nana: Leader of the Mimbreno Apache. In the film, Nana hopes to join
forces with Victorio's tribe to raid the New Mexico territory.
Victorio: The leader of the Mescalero Apache. Victorio is an
excellent strategist; his maneuvers rival some of the U.S. military's
leading generals. He and Nana refused to live on U.S. reservations.
Troop H and Victorio's Movements in BUFFALO SOLDIERS
The map below depicts the movement of the Buffalo Soldiers and
Victorio in the Rattlesnake Springs campaign. Refer to this map while viewing
to help you follow the events of the film.
- July 30, after fighting with Victorio at Tinaja de las Palmas, Grierson
heads to Eagle Springs with Troops A, C, and G, Tenth Cavalry. Company H
of the 24th Infantry, and Company H, Tenth Cavalry, were already there.
- August 2, leaving part of his command at Eagle Springs, Grierson heads
for Van Horn Wells.
- Troop H moves toward Alamo Springs and engages Victorio's band in a
running battle. Knowing that Victorio will head to the only water hole
available - Rattlesnake Springs - Grierson begins a desperate race to beat
Victorio there. Troop H rides 65 miles in less than 21 hours, arriving two
hours in advance of Victorio and his men.
- The Battle of Rattlesnake Springs. Troops from the Tenth Cavalry and
other units outmaneuver Victorio. With heavy losses, Victorio is forced
to retreat back to Mexico. Weeks later, he is killed by Mexican Federalizes.
| 1 - Eagle Springs | 3 - Alamo Springs |
| 2 - Van Horn Wells | 4 - Rattlesnake Springs |
African-American Soldiers & American Indians in the West
Although the African-American troops volunteered for the
peacetime army to help pave the way for westward expansion, most of the
White settlers did not want to live near the African-American troops.
Therefore, the Buffalo Soldiers were scattered across remote areas of the
American frontier.
- Research the Indian Wars and use the map below to discuss the role of the
Buffalo Soldiers in the Western campaign.
- Compare this map with one listing the boom towns of the same time period.
Draw conclusions about the impact of racism on the military.
- Why do you think there are no Buffalo Soldiers forts on the West coast?
To help answer the question, research the tribes that were located in these
territories.
- Create a map depicting the American Indian population in 1997. How does
the map here compare? How do you account for the differences?
| 1 - Fort Assiniboine | 26 - Fort Niobrara | 51 - Fort Wingate |
| 2 - Fort Shaw | 27 - Fort Robinson | 52 - Fort Union |
| 3 - Fort Missoula | 28 - Fort McPherson | 53 - Fort Bascom |
| 4 - Fort Keogh | 29 - Fort Wallace | 54 - Fort Craig |
| 5 - Fort Custer | 30 - Fort Riley | 55 - Fort Stanton |
| 6 - Fort Buford | 31 - Fort Leavenworth | 56 - Fort McRae |
| 7 - Fort Totten | 32 - Fort Hays | 57 - Fort Bayard |
| 8 - Fort Rice | 33 - Fort Harker | 58 - Fort Cummings |
| 9 - Fort Yates | 34 - Fort Zarah | 59 - Fort Elliot |
| 10 - Fort McKinney | 35 - Fort Larned | 60 - Palo Duro Canyon |
| 11 - Fort Washakie | 36 - Fort Boocher | 61 - Fort Richardson |
| 12 - Fort D.A. Russell | 37 - Fort Dodge | 62 - Fort Griffin |
| 13 - Fort Sully | 38 - Fort Supply | 63 - Fort Concho |
| 14 - Pine Ridge Reservation | 39 - Fort Gibson | 64 - Fort Blass |
| 15 - Fort Hale | 40 - Fort Reno | 65 - Fort Stockton |
| 16 - Wounded Knee | 41 - Fort Sill | 66 - Camp Quitman |
| 17 - Fort Randall | 42 - Fort Arbukle | 67 - Fort Davis |
| 18 - Fort Snelling | 43 - Fort Verde | 68 - Camp Pena Colorado |
| 19 - Fort Douglas | 44 - Fort Apache | 69 - Fort Hudson |
| 20 - Fort Hornburgh | 45 - Fort McDowell | 70 - Fort McKavett |
| 21 - Fort Du Chesne | 46 - Fort Thomas | 71 - Fort Clark |
| 22 - Beecher Island | 47 - Camp San Carlos | 72 - Fort Duncan |
| 23 - Fort Lyon | 48 - Fort Grant | 73 - Ringgold |
| 24 - Fort Garland | 49 - Fort Bowie |
| 25 - Fort Lewis | 50 - Fort Huachuca |
THEME: Docudrama vs. Documentary
"The novelist and the historian have equally important
roles to play in
understanding our past, but they should never forget they are on separate
roads to the truth."
Robert Penn Warren, novelist, 1969
Buffalo Soldiers, the TNT docudrama, and Buffalo Soldiers
histories share a
common goal: to illustrate the relevance of a significant group of soldiers
in our nation's history. Buffalo Soldiers seeks to illuminate the experience
of an individual soldier using historical events as a backdrop. Use the
Student Handout page and the following discussion questions and activities to encourage
students to analyze the differences between docudrama and documentary and to
respond to the universal themes of racism, patriotism and human dignity.
Discussion Before Viewing BUFFALO SOLDIERS
- Discuss with your students how the same story can be told
in different forms of media (e.g. Oliver Stone's JFK, history books,
Life
magazine, etc.). What function does the media have (to entertain, inform,
persuade)? What responsibilities do viewers have in deciphering their
messages?
- Define and discuss the terms dramatic license, bias, docudrama and
documentary (e.g. docudramas: pop culture films; documentaries:
Ken Burns'
Civil War, Jeremy Isaacs' World at War). What do your
students think is the
purpose behind making a docudrama rather than a documentary? (Possible
responses: to entertain, to illicit emotional response, to inform, to educate,
to pose questions).
- Have your students identify any event in history. What questions must
they ask in order to determine if their knowledge of it is a true account?
(Questions may include: How did we learn about this event? From whose
perspective was it told? Is it important that the account is accurate? Why or
why not?
- Have your students read the Historical
Backdrop, timeline and maps. For
a detailed account of the events depicted in the film, read William Leckie's
book Buffalo Soldiers, pp. 223-229. While they view Buffalo Soldiers, ask
your students to note elements that would support that this is a docudrama
rather than a documentary.
After Viewing Discussion Questions & Activities
- Whose Story Is It?
Discussion - Using the comparison chart on the Student Handout,
ask students to compare actual historical events with
the filmmaker's version. Why do your students think the producers and
directors made these changes? How important are the facts to understanding
the history of the Buffalo Soldiers? Have your students discuss the pros
and cons of delivering a film as docudrama rather than documentary. Refer
students to Robert Penn Warren's quote above. Substituting "docudrama" for
"novelist," challenge students to discuss what roles they think the docudrama
producer and the historian play in telling the story of the Buffalo Soldiers?
How might the path taken by the filmmaker differ from that taken by a
historian? Do your students think these roads are separate or might they
cross?
Activity
Have students play the role of the script writer whose responsibility it is to adapt the script to make it more historically accurate. Students should address the following concerns: 1) Where would they find the information to make the film accurate? 2) From whose perspective would they write? When students present their rewritten script to the class, they should be prepared to defend their decisions.
To understand the importance of perspective when learning about history, students can write a movie review from the perspective of 1) a descendent of a Buffalo Soldier; 2) a descendent of the Apache; 3) a descendent of General Pike; 4) a historian; 5) a student of history. Have them present and justify their review. Discuss the similarities and differences among the presentations.
- In Their Own Words?
Discussion - Buffalo Soldiers explores a moral dilemma that may or may
not have been experienced by the actual Buffalo Soldiers. Encourage students
to use the Comments From the Producers to answer, "What message is conveyed
by the film?" Have your students debate the following: Should actions and
decisions made by people living in the 19th century be judged in their
historical context or can we judge them using 20th century standards?
Activity
Have your students analyze their textbook accounts of western expansion. How could their textbook best portray the Buffalo Soldiers? Referring to the film and other primary and secondary resources, students can write copy and submit it with a letter to the textbook editor. In anticipation of potential reactions by the editor, your students should provide solid reasons for why their text should be included in future editions.
Student Handout: Docudrama vs. Documentary
Review the table illustrating the differences
between a docudrama and a documentary. Events depicted in the film are
juxtaposed with actual historical events as noted by historian William Leckie
in Buffalo Soldiers: A Narrative of the Negro Cavalry in the West.
Compare: Drama vs. History
| TNT's BUFFALO SOLDIERS: A Docudrama |
Buffalo Soldiers: A Narrative of the Negro Cavalry in the West: A Textbook
History |
| Buffalo Soldier William Christy, revered by Sergeant Major Wyatt, is killed
in an Apache attack. |
William Christy was stationed at Fort Larned, KS, and was killed in an Indian
attack prior to the Rattlesnake Springs incident. |
| Nana is captured by the Buffalo Soldiers and used to get to Victorio. |
Buffalo Soldiers capture Nana weeks after Victorio is killed by the
Mexican government. |
| Nana's granddaughter is captured with Nana. |
This female warrior was, in fact, Lozen, one of Nana's wives and also
Victorio's sister. She was considered by her people to be a shaman. |
| Colonel Grierson takes all of Troop H with him to pursue Victorio. |
Grierson had only his son and eight Buffalo Soldiers with him. He sent for
reinforcements. |
| Colonel Grierson is wounded before the troops reach Rattlesnake Springs. |
Grierson was not wounded. He continued with Troop H and pursued Victorio to
Mexico. |
| Sergeant Major Wyatt and his troops march long and far to reach
Rattlesnake Springs before Victorio. |
Buffalo Soldiers traveled 65 miles in less than 24 hours to reach
Rattlesnake Springs. |
| When Buffalo Soldiers encounter Victorio and his Apaches, John Horse
translates a conversation between Wyatt and Victorio. |
As Victorio approached, Troop H opened fire. The Apaches failed to go
around the troops to get to the water and many were killed. Buffalo Soldiers
captured Victorio's supply camp. |
| Sergeant Major Wyatt allows Victorio and his people to escape from
Rattlesnake Springs. |
Victorio and his Apaches were driven out of the Texas territory and into
Mexico by Colonel Grierson and his Buffalo Soldiers. |
Comments From the Producers
Danny Glover (Executive Producer/Wyatt):
"We've taken a great deal of dramatic liberty with this. I'm sure that if we
looked upon accounts we may find some mention where these men [Buffalo Soldiers]
rebelled in some sort of way.... [Washington Wyatt] has this sense of having to
prove himself, a sense of having responsibility...the man lives by the book.
He has become the perfect soldier...he follows regulation...he becomes obsessed
with...catching Victorio...he is looking for an opportunity to be validated."
John Watson (Executive Producer):
"The story deals with a fictional incident, something that may have happened,
may not have happened, in which [Wyatt] is forced to confront his conscience...
how to deal with a group of Apaches who he is bound on capturing...his personal
pride staked in capturing Victorio. And when he actually has a chance to deliver
on that goal he has to confront the morality of that decision. It is dealing
with issues of race, and unfortunately issues of race are still very much part
of our society. It sets out to tell in a very truthful, uncompromising way,
a story and doesn't pull any punches...how cruel all groups were."
Carl Lumbly (John Horse):
"The moral dilemma set up was one which probably only hit a few of them. But
for a few it was a problem because here were not only native people but, the
original people. Many had taken in Black people who had run from slavery. There
was a lot of intermarriage that took place and not only in the Seminole
territory. The idea of having been brought from another land to conquer the
people who were indigenous to this place presented a moral dilemma."
THEME: Racism & the Military
African-Americans have served bravely in the U.S. military since the American
Revolution. However, in every conflict they confronted two enemies
simultaneously: the enemies of their nation and the enemy of racism within
the armed forces and society in general. The discussion questions and activities
below challenge students to examine the film's assertion that the Buffalo
Soldiers faced a great moral dilemma: fighting for a country that denied them
freedom and equality, and denying those same rights to another persecuted
minority.
Discussion Before Viewing BUFFALO SOLDIERS
- Ask your students to define racism. Pose the following questions:
Where does racism come from? Why does racism persist?
- Referencing the timeline and Historical Backdrop, discuss the history
of African-Americans in the military. Discuss the moral dilemma of joining
the military to defend a country that discriminates against your race,
religion or ethnic group. Why might someone join the military under these
circumstances? Why did the Buffalo Soldiers join the military? Why did
they stay?
- Invite to your classroom an African-American or other minority soldier.
Ask him/her to discuss the treatment of minorities in the military. Does
racism exist in the military today? How are infractions dealt with compared
to 100 years ago?
After Viewing Discussion
- Why Join the Military?
Discussion - Discuss instances of racism depicted in Buffalo Soldiers
and what African-Americans faced when joining the military. Explore reasons
why Wyatt stays in the military. Why does he not speak up for his rights?
How were the reactions of the other soldiers similar to or different from
what you would expect from a civilian? How do students account for this?
American-Indians, like the African-Americans, served faithfully in the
U.S. military (see timeline in Historical Backdrop.) In light of Victorio's
statements at the end of the film, and considering the American-Indian
plight, discuss why American-Indians would volunteer to fight for the U.S.
government.
Activity
Have your students create a chart, labeling one side: Reasons to Join and the
other side Reasons Not to Join. Using the Historical
Backdrop, timeline, the film and the Student Handout,
students should fill in the chart as they weigh the pros and cons for why African-Americans would join the military.
Historically, African-Americans have struggled for the right to fight for their country. By the Vietnam conflict, however, there were charges that a disproportionate number were being placed on the front lines of battle. Have students research the changing roles of African-Americans in the U.S. military, comparing the treatment, conditions and opportunities for African-American soldiers in the military in the 1800s with modern day examples. How do students account for the changes?
- Civil Disobedience vs. Following Orders
Discussion - During the Mexican War, essayist Henry David
Thoreau wrote Civil Disobedience in protest of a war being fought to
extend slavery. More than 100 years later, Martin Luther King, Jr. wrote
Letter from a Birmingham Jail. Both essays emphasize that laws
that deal with moral issues, matters of right and wrong, must not be obeyed
merely because they are laws. To obey or disobey such laws must be decided
by each individual according to his or her conscience.
Buffalo Soldiers illustrates the powerful conflict between duty and
individual culpability. Why did Wyatt and the other Buffalo Soldiers follow
the orders of their superiors? Did they ever question their orders? Why was
Wyatt's decision so difficult? Do students agree or disagree with his
decision?
Activity
Referencing Civil Disobedience and Letter From a Birmingham Jail,
have students
examine the issue of conscience vs. regulation in other U.S. military
engagements. In which conflicts might soldiers have faced this moral
dilemma (e.g. Nuremberg Trials, Japanese Internment during WWII, My Lai/Vietnam
Conflict). Have students debate the right of a soldier to make a moral decision
that is in direct conflict with his/her orders.
Student Handout: Racism & the Military
Use the these resources to help your students understand and analyze the
impact of racism in the military.
Voices From TNT's BUFFALO SOLDIERS
"No reflection on Sergeants Wyatt and Christy. They're
not
trained for command. Their kind relays orders. They don't give them."
-General Pike
"Command niggers? General, you're asking me to throw away my career."
-Major Carr
"And what would your late father think of your willingness to serve with field
nigras, Captain Calhoun?"
-Major Carr to Captain Calhoun
"Keep your troops back, Captain Calhoun. Regulations. Colored companies
fifteen yards behind white."
-General Pike to Captain Calhoun
"Colored soldiers not supposed to ride through town with fanfare. Regulations,
Captain."
-Wyatt explains to Calhoun
"Army bears you no love. None of you They endure you. They'll endure you 'til
they've wiped all the tribes from the slate-with your blood. Then they'll cut
you so loose, you'll trip an' hang yourself on the rope. Where the hell is your
pride, Sergeant Major?"
-John Horse to Wyatt and other Buffalo Soldiers
"Reservation Injuns. Agency dogooder called 'em tame.' Well, you can feed 'em
plum pudding 'an put white clothes on their backs; theyÕre still just Apaches."
-Oran Draper, Texas Ranger
"Witch doctors. Old fools smearing themselves with horse dung and corn meal,
praying for the Great Sky father to make the white-eyes go away."
-Major Carr
Voices From History
- "You should see this post! The one darkey bugler sounds
every call on the board - at least, the bugler toots something so absurd,
and as much like the true call as a cow's low. The 'black-faced and shiney-
eyed' were drilling right on the grass of the parade ground...while the
sergeant drilled one squad, another rolled on the ground like apes....
Really, if I were not afraid, these things would be funny."
-General Custer in Kansas and Texas, Elizabeth Bacon Custer 1889, pp.
536-537
- During the debate of Bill #138, a Congressman stated: "I wish to
express my thought that the people of my country are able to maintain
themselves, and do not need to be maintained by an inferior race....
Soldiers are men of arms, as are their officers and commanders. They
must belong to the ruling forces, and should not belong to the inferior
forces..... This undertaking to place a lower, inferior, different race
upon a level with the white manÕs race, in arms is against the laws that
lie at the foundation of true republicanism.."
-Congressional Record
- "We return. We return from fighting. We return fighting."
-W.E.B. DuBois, after WWI
- "Men of Color to Arms! Liberty won only by White men would lose half
its luster."
-Frederick Douglass, during the Civil War
- "We the soldiers of the [Tenth Cavalry] U.S. Army, do hereby warn
the first and last time all citizens and cowboys, etc. of San Angelo and
vicinity to recognize our right of way as just and peaceable men. If we do
not receive justice and fair play, which we must have, someone will suffer -
if not the guilty, the innocent. It has gone too far, justice or death."
-Signed U.S. Soldiers, San Saba News, February 12, 1881: Organizational
Returns (text from a handbill posted by African-American troops after the
murder of one of their troopers)
- In 1893, in Crawford, Nebraska, the attempted lynching of a former
member of the Ninth Cavalry prompted this open letter to the Omaha
Progress: "If we are not protected when we visit Crawford, we will
protect ourselves regardless of the consequences.... You shall not
outrage us and our people right under the shadow of 'Old Glory' while
we have shot and shell."
-Omaha Progress, April 29, 1893
THEME: Broken Promises & Broken Dreams
Buffalo Soldiers conveys a powerful message about the cruelty groups can have
toward one another. The director illustrates the common experiences of two
oppressed groups: the Buffalo Soldiers and the American Indians. Your students
can explore this further by comparing the film's depiction of each group with
an historical analysis of their common struggle for freedom and equality.
Discussion Before Viewing BUFFALO SOLDIERS
- Have your students explore the historical relationship between the U.S.
government and the American Indians. How did the U.S. goal of Manifest
Destiny affect the life of American Indians on the western frontier in the
1800s? How did the U.S. justify its treatment of the Indians?
- Students should research the treaties that were signed between the
Apache and the U.S. government. What were the goals of the American
Indians? What were the goals of the U.S. government? Could each group's
goals be realized?
- Compare the U.S. policy of Indian removal with the enslavement of and
discrimination towards African-Americans. How do your students account for
the differences and the similarities?
After Viewing Discussion
- Broken Promises & Broken Dreams
Discussion - Although the meeting that takes place between Wyatt and Victorio is fictional, the film encourages viewers to imagine what the soldiers must have been thinking. Have your students discuss how the producer conveys his message. How does the audience know the soldiers are questioning their mission? What evidence exists that shows the soldiers felt a kinship with the Apache?
Activity
Consider the terms of the treaty on the resource page. What were the Apaches
promised by the U.S. government? Compare these promises with those the U.S.
government made to the African-Americans after the Civil War. In what ways did
the government break its promises to each of these groups?
Research the role of the government in the removal of the American Indians from
their land and the de facto discrimination against African-Americans. Referencing
the Constitution from 1880 and the sample treaty, students should
explore which arguments the African-Americans and American Indians could have used
in a lawsuit against the federal government. Have your students gather evidence
for either the U.S., the African-Americans or the American Indians.
Stage a mock trial with your students.
African-Americans and American Indians have taken different paths toward realizing their dreams, and the U.S. government has enacted different laws to rectify the injustices of the past. Using the Student Handout and other primary and secondary resources, have students research and compare the ways in which African-Americans and American Indians have struggled for equality. How do students account for the similarities? Differences?
- A Common Struggle
Discussion - Colonel Grierson interjects "Does anyone in this room
remember who the real enemy is?" Who did the U.S. military consider to
be the enemy? Who did the soldiers in Buffalo Soldiers consider to be the
enemy? What role did racism and discrimination have in determining the
enemy? Who were the enemies of the Apache nation? What makes someone an
enemy? Are enemy lines defined or blurred in the film? The character of
John Horse symbolizes the commonalties between the two groups. According
to historical accounts, American Indians adopted runaway slaves, which
often resulted in intermarriage. Have your students examine the relationship
between John Horse and Wyatt. Why is there tension between the two men? How
do they resolve their conflict? How does John Horse help Wyatt face his
internal struggle? Have your students discuss both John Horse's quote, "I
am a free man - I come and go for my reasons...can you say the same?" and
Victorio's quote, "We will not be slaves like you...why do you murder us
for people who made you feel like cattle?" As depicted in the film, how
did John Horse and Victorio judge the way in which African-Americans responded
to their treatment by the U.S. government? What message does the filmmaker try
to convey? Do students agree with this message?
Activity
Compare and contrast events in the 19th century, (i.e. Indian removal, slavery,
etc.) with events that are currently taking place worldwide. In light of the
moral dilemma explored in Buffalo Soldiers, have students discuss historian George
Santayana's quote, "Those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it."
Student Handout: Broken Promises and Broken Dreams
Use the following resources to examine the similarities and
differences between the African-American and American Indian struggles to be free,
and to analyze the film's fictional portrayal of the relationship between the two
subjugated groups.
Treaty With the Apache, 1952
ARTICLE 2.
...here and after the signing of this Treaty hostilities between the contracting parties shall forever cease, and perpetual peace and amity shall forever exist between said Indians and the Government and people of the United States.
ARTICLE 6.
Should any citizen of the United States, or other person or persons subject to the laws of the United States, murder, rob, or otherwise maltreat any Apache Indian or Indians, he or they shall be arrested or tried, and upon conviction, shall be subject to all the penalties provided by law for the protection of the persons and property of the people of the said States.
ARTICLE 9.
Relying confidently upon the justice and the liberality of the aforesaid government, and anxious to remove every possible cause that might disturb their peace and quiet, it is agreed by the aforesaid Apaches that the government of the U.S. shall at its earliest convenience designate, settle and adjust their territorial boundaries, and pass and execute in their territory such laws as may be deemed conducive to the prosperity and happiness of said Indians.
ARTICLE 10.
For and in consideration of the faithful performance of all the stipulations
herein contained, by the said Apache's Indians, the government of the United
States will grant to said Indians such donations, presents, and implements, and adopt such other liberal and humane measures of aid that the government may deem meet and proper.
Milestones in American Indian Civil Rights
1871
Congress ends treaty-making with American Indians.
1880s
American Indians are moved to reservations, considered "wards" of the government.
1924
U.S. extends American citizenship to all American Indians born within the territorial limits of the United States.
1934
Indian "New Deal" aims to halt the sale of American Indian land, to restore tribal land-holding, to rebuild the tribes and promote tribal culture.
1950s
President Eisenhower enacts "termination" and "relocation" programs; ends all federal involvement with American Indians and transfers power to the states.
1969
American Indians seize Alcatraz Island, demanding it be recognized as a cultural center.
1972
The militant AIM (American Indian Movement) occupies the offices of the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) in Washington, D.C.
1973
More than 200 armed members of AIM take over the village of Wounded Knee in South Dakota.
1975
Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act of 1975.
1970s
American Indians go to the courts to win back their lands; many succeed.
Indian reservations contain an estimated 16 percent of the nation's natural
energy resources.
1988
Congress passes the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act; nearly 130 tribes in 24 states are involved in some kind of gaming.
1996
President Clinton declares November National American Indian Heritage Month.

TNT's Buffalo Soldiers provides a window into the
experiences of one group of Black soldiers who served during one of the
most powerful and least understood chapters in our nation's history.
Because Buffalo Soldiers is a docudrama, the events depicted in the film
are intended to elicit an emotional response to history and represent broad
themes rather than actual historical fact. As such, Buffalo Soldiers should
be viewed solely in its historical context as an examination of heroic men
whose courage, integrity and dignity were challenged on the American frontier.
The Buffalo Soldiers
After the Civil War, Congress passed Bill #138 which reorganized the peacetime military. Provisions in this bill created six regiments of Black troops, four infantry (foot soldiers) and two-cavalry (on horseback). The Ninth was placed under the command of Colonel Edward Hatch and the Tenth under the command of Colonel Benjamin Grierson.
Joining the Military
Blacks from the North and South enlisted in droves. To most, the military
was an opportunity for a career. As historian Anthony Powell states, "This
would be the only part of America that America would allow the colored man
to have." Black soldiers were paid the same $13 per month as their White counterparts and received the same food, uniforms and equipment.
Both former slaves and free Blacks entered the U.S. military in the 1800s. Because of restrictions placed on education at the time, many of the enlistees were illiterate. To remedy the situation, the government established the Regimental Chaplin, whose primary objective was to teach the soldiers to read and write, enabling them to fill out reports and do other paperwork required by the army. Access to a free education provided Black soldiers the opportunity to erase the stigma of illiteracy and move closer toward equality with Whites.
Records reveal that the African-American troops performed exceptionally. The soldiers believed their performance was representative of the entire African-American population, and so they sought to do their best at every turn.
Despite segregation and discrimination, the Buffalo Soldier regiments exhibited high rates of reenlistment and low instances of desertion and alcoholism when compared to other troops. Their record of distinguished service eventually silenced many critics and earned praise from many high ranking officers.
The Indian Wars
Like White troops, one of the assignments of the Buffalo Soldiers was to
escort tribes to designated reservations, fight them when they tried to
preserve their traditional way of life and protect settlers from attacks.
Of the 139 Indian campaigns launched between 1866 and 1890, a large percentage
involved Black troops. While TNT's Buffalo Soldiers asks "what did the Buffalo
Soldiers think of their assignment?" the men of the these regiments had little
choice when orders demanded that they remove American Indians from their native
lands. This was government policy, and the Buffalo Soldiers carried out their
orders out of a sense of duty and commitment to their country and the oath they
had taken to the flag of the Republic.
Other Duties of the Buffalo Soldiers
The Buffalo Soldiers also built and defended the telegraph lines, built and repaired forts,which helped establish foundations for future towns. They were involved in the settling of railroad/union disputes, assisted the local authorities in settling disputes between the White settlers, mapped the vast territories in New Mexico and Arizona, marked the water holes, helped settlers find safe places to live, and protected railroad workers.
Origin of the Name
Indians were said to have associated the fur between the horns of the bison with the curly hair of the African-American troops. And the soldiers demonstrated the fearlessness and courage of the buffalo. The name Buffalo Soldier stuck, and the soldiers wore it with pride.
The Apache
When White settlers began moving into the southwestern territory in the middle
of the 19th century, they were challenged by the Apache, Navajo, Comanches, Ute,
Lipan, Kiowa, Cheyenne, and Arapaho. The Apache were a nomadic people, raiders
who fought for their land and their way of life. They were led by some of.
history's most successful warriors: Cochise, Geronimo, Mangas Coloradas, Nana,
and Victorio. The name "Apache," a Zuni adaptation from the word "apachu," means
"enemy." This great enemy was known for cunning, trickery, courage, speed, and
military genius.
After years of conflict, the Apache nation signed several treaties with the
U.S. government that transferred them to reservations in New Mexico and Arizona.
But promises of protection and support were broken before the ink was dry.
Stripped of their nomadic traditions, the Apache wereforced to become farmers
on unforgiving land. Years later, having finally adapted to the land, the
Apaches were again displaced, this time by settlers. In addition, copper and
silver prospectors mined the very same land, taking the earth's riches and
giving nothing in return. And while the treaties promised the Apache people
food and supplies, the government again came up short - supplies were less
than adequate, often tainted and diseased, and sometimes nonexistent.
In protest, in 1879 Victorio and his followers, along with Nana, left the
reservation and headed to Mexico. Because the Mexican government would not
allow the U.S. military to enter Mexican soil, the U.S. cavalry's only means
to confine Victorio to Mexico was to guard the border.
On July 30, 1880, Colonel Grierson and a handful of soldiers from the Tenth Cavalry fought Victorio at Tinaja de las Palmas, Texas. Victorio was defeated and pushed back into Mexico. On his next attempt, Victorio headed for Rattlesnake Springs, NM. It was here that the great warrior aced defeat at the hands of Grierson and the Tenth. Rattlesnake Springs was a decisive U.S. tactical victory. Victorio was pushed back to Mexico for the last time and was eventually killed by the Mexican forces and their Indian auxiliaries.
TIMELINE: African-American & American Indian Troops in the Military
- African-American
*American Indian
1770
- March 5, at the Boston Massacre, Crispus Attucks is killed by British forces.
1775-1783 American Revolution
- Congress reluctantly agrees to enlist African-Americans into the service; approximately 7,000 soldiers and sailors sign up to defend the United States.
* American Indians fight on both sides.
1812-1815 The War of 1812
- The battles of New Orleans and Lake Erie have African-American representation. The men were promised freedom if successful.
1861-1865 - The Civil War
- Approximately 186,000 African-American troops served in union regiments. More than 33,000 died.
* American Indians fight on both sides.
1866-1890
- 1866, Congress passes Bill #138, which establishes six regiments of Black troops, four infantry and two cavalry.
- Buffalo Soldiers help carry out the U.S. government's policy of westward expansion.
1898 - Spanish-American War
- The Buffalo Soldiers, under Captain "Black Jack" Pershing, lead the charge up San Juan Hill.
1914-1918 - World War I
- More than 400,000 African-American troops fight against the Germans.
* 6,000 of the 8,000 American Indians who fought were volunteers.
1941-1945 - World War II
- More than one million African-American troops fight against the Axis powers.
* 25,000 American Indian men and women fight for democracy. Navajo Marines language is used as a secret code.
1948
-* President Truman orders an end to segregation of troops in the military with the signing of Executive Order #9981.
1950-1953 - The Korean War
- By the end of this conflict the armed forces are officially integrated.
* An American Indian wins the Congressional Medal of Honor.
1965-1975 - The Vietnam Conflict
- Twenty African-Americans win the Congressional Medal of Honor. By 1966, they made up almost 16 percent of all draftees. By 1967, 20 percent of army fatalities are African-American.
* 41,500 American Indians served.
1971
- Concerns over the Vietnam conflict, the inequality in domestic and military society, set off a series of race riots, sit down strikes and other disruptions.
1975
- "Chappie" Daniel James is the first African-American four star general.
1989
- Colin Powell is the first African-American to be selected as Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.
1990-1991 - The Persian Gulf War
* 3,000 American Indians served. Three were among those killed in action.
1992
- Over 400,000 African-American servicemen and women on active dutyÐ30% of the army, 20% of the marines and 13% of the navy. The Buffalo Soldier Monument is dedicated at Ft. Leavenworth, Kansas.
* One out of every four American Indian males is a military veteran. Forty-six percent of tribal leaders today are veterans.
1994
- The U.S. Postal Service issues the commemorative Buffalo Soldier stamp.
The Legacy of the Buffalo Soldiers
"Look at him. Soldier of the nation. Eagles on his
buttons, crossed sabres on his canteen, a rifle in his hand, a pistol on his hip.
Courageous, iron will.... The Buffalo Soldier believed that hatred and bigotry
and prejudice could not defeat him, that through his pain and sacrifice they
would be destroyed for the evil things they are."
-General Colin L. Powell, at the unveiling of the Buffalo Soldier Monument at Fort Leavenworth, KS
- Between 1866 and 1912, 23 Buffalo Soldiers and/or Seminole Scouts received the Congressional Medal of Honor.
- There is no documentation showing Buffalo Soldiers performing any type of mutilation or pillage toward their enemies.
- The record will show that Buffalo Soldiers performed their duty well, creating a pride not only in their units, but for their country and the flag it represented, and to the entire African-American race.

Books and Magazines
- The Buffalo Soldiers: A Narrative of the Negro Cavalry in the
West, William Leckie
- The Forgotten Heroes: The Story of the Buffalo Soldiers, Clinton
Cox
- Cobblestone - Buffalo Soldiers, February 1995, Volume Sixteen,
Number II, History of Indian White Relations, Smithsonian Institute
- Men-A-Marching, Frank P. Langallier, Colorado Heritage magazine,
Spring 1996
- Aftrican Americans: Voices of Triumph, Time-Life custom
Publishing
Internet Sites
- http://tnt.turner.com
- http://learning.turner.com
- http://www.horseworld.com/imh/buf/buf1.html
- http://www.charm.net/~fdiggs/buffalo/history.html
- http://www.wiz-worx.com/366th/buffalo.htm
- http://www.coax.net/people/LWF/buffpage.htm
- http://www.clements.umich.edu/Photogal/People.html
- http://www.fortconcho.com (select Living History)
Fax completed Evaluation to 770-739-7085.